Skip to main content

Advertisement

Table 8 2-Sample T test between MAXI and the second best approach (JILP or JRCAR)

From: Multi-objective routing aware of mixed IoT traffic for low-cost wireless Backhauls

   MAXI Second Best Approach   
Result Figure Mean Std. Dev. Mean Std. Dev. P-value Approach
PLR Packet Loss Rate 50 node. Figure 4 20.88% 4.1777 22.85% 3.7374 0.0291798 JILP
Throughput - (kbps) 50 nodes Figure 5 2099.60 176.7813 1999.80 214.1429 0.0258763 JRCAR
PLR Packet Loss Rate 3 interferer nodes Figure 10.a 3.88% 3.64508 8.77% 4.3487 6.01526e-7 JRCAR
PLR Packet Loss Rate 4 interferer nodes Figure 10.a 4.71% 3.79077 10.87% 4.7405 1.12835e-8 JRCAR
PLR Packet Loss Rate 3 interferer nodes Figure 10.b 14.73% 6.0360 20.68% 5.1981 0.000010434 JRCAR
PLR Packet Loss Rate 4 interferer nodes Figure 10.b 16.59% 5.8581 21.74% 6.4999 0.000375204 JRCAR
PLR Packet Loss Rate 3 interferer nodes Figure 10.c 10.38% 6.3970 15.27% 5.8087 0.0005940690 JILP
PLR Packet Loss Rate 4 interferer nodes Figure 10.c 11.39% 6.4491 18.20% 6.2584 0.0771206e-4 JRCAR
PLR Packet Loss Rate 3 interferer nodes Figure 10.d 26.11% 6.6300 28.63% 6.0063 0.078334* JRCAR
PLR Packet Loss Rate 4 interferer nodes Figure 10.d 25.46% 6.9406 29.58% 6.5963 0.0078889 JRCAR
PLR Packet Loss Rate 3 interferer nodes Figure 10.e 24.92% 5.7788 28.29% 7.0203 0.0214786 JILP
PLR Packet Loss Rate 4 interferer nodes Figure 10.e 25.46% 6.6399 29.50% 7.0977 0.0103543 JRCAR
Throughput - (kbps) 3 interferer nodes Figure 11.a 0.0142 0.0005 0.0129 0.0007 4.73843e-13 JILP
Throughput - (kbps) 4 interferer nodes Figure 11.a 0.0141 0.0005 0.0132 0.0007 3.87685e-9 JRCAR
Throughput - (kbps) 3 interferer nodes Figure 11.b 5.6153 7.4809 3.8274 3.0998 0.168543* JILP
Throughput - (kbps) 4 interferer nodes Figure 11.b 4.2828 1.8386 3.6457 0.2723 0.0360313 JRCAR
Throughput - (kbps) 3 interferer nodes Figure 11.c 42.5862 6.0842 37.7976 0.2702 0.00001364 JILP
Throughput - (kbps) 4 interferer nodes Figure 11.c 39.6792 3.0428 37.1380 3.0790 0.00038309 JRCAR
Throughput - (kbps) 3 interferer nodes Figure 11.d 894.7601 82.7290 903.9110 88.4366 0.634047* JRCAR
Throughput - (kbps) 4 interferer nodes Figure 11.d 908.0184 91.2944 900.2777 78.0516 0.684719* JRCAR
Throughput - (kbps) 3 interferer nodes Figure 11.e 271.6090 21.8762 258.0036 19.8047 0.0046429 JRCAR
Throughput - (kbps) 4 interferer nodes Figure 11.e 268.8379 21.9425 257.3389 26.0504 0.0359653 JRCAR
  1. *samples with a P-value ≥ 0.05